Editors'Pick
To leave a review you need to be logged in
Editor’s Pick is your online source for top quality beauty and wellness products at low cost prices that don’t break the bank. Shop online from our curated selection of skin care, hair care, makeup, fashion, and other beauty and wellness products. Buy the brands you love with the savings and convenience of online shopping.
Reviews 152
Renee
Feb 13,2025Bought two Perricone MD products. Both were 7 months past the expiration date and smelled spoiled. It's been 2 days since I reached out to them to initiate a return and they still have not responded.
Anonymous
Jan 24,2025This website is not an authorized retailer for any of these brands. They purchase their products through the grey market. They are able to discount so highly because of where they purchase, as they can buy under wholesale cost. Multiple brands have and will be filing law suits against them for selling their product with no authorization. The CEO of Editor’s Pick, Kathryn McDavid is not a real person. She even has a fake LinkedIn profile. If the companies she “worked for” were called, they would not be able to verify employment simply because she does not exist. Her information is even attached to the company info on the BBB.
Tina Conlon
Jan 14,2025Poor customer service, sent them an email on my order and got an auto reply that someone will get back to me. Did not hear from them at all, even after a follow up. Not good customer service!
JANE MARIA NOGUEIRA DE FRANCIS
Jan 12,2025I didn’t receive my bought until now! I’m sad with this situation.
MIKE LISAGOR
Jan 04,2025Great site, great cologne and great price.
Beach Life
Dec 31,2024I have ordered 2 items from Editor’s Pick and I have been happy with both purchases-Revision C+ Correcting Complex 30% and Dr. Dennis Gross Extra Strength Peel Pads. Both are real items because I use these products almost everyday. The date for the peel pads is 09/27 and IDK if Revision has expiration dates on their products, but the box was sealed and I’m sure it is the same product I have purchased in the Dermatologist’s office. I will continue to order from them because they offer the best prices on quality skincare products.
Karina
Dec 11,2024Products don't have expiration dates and don't come shrink wrapped. Had an adverse reaction and tried calling/emailing the company and ZERO response. I challenge anyone to call (646)892-9029 and get anyone on the phone. Products are on sale bc they are not the real deal. So disgusted with this company. Stay far away bc it's a ripoff.
Wendy
Dec 10,2024Editor’s Pick is amazing! They ship everything so fast! Plus, I’m able to find products here that I haven’t been able to find anywhere else. Will definitely be my place to shop from now on!
Darlene
Dec 02,2024I received notification from DHL product delivered on Nov 22nd. To date there’s still no sign of product. I contacted DHL who indicated they would follow up with local post office. I left voice mail messages for Editor’s Pick on Nov 25 & Nov 27. Today is Dec 2nd. I have no product, no follow up response from anyone and obviously no refund. It would be appreciated if someone would actually respond and find a resolution.
Karen Wanner Nester
Nov 19,2024Everything I have ordered has been in perfect condition and shipped fast. I love this site!!
Fara Desir
Nov 05,2024I believe there products are fake. I’ve been using PCA pigment bar for the last 5 years. I decided to look into a cheaper site which was this one. I started using it on vacation in Jamaican I instantly felt burning on my face. I thought cleaning products must’ve gotten on my facial sponge. I was left with burnt marks on a parts of my face. I Continue using the product for three months not realizing what was going on, and my face is a totally different complexion than my body. My husband ask me if I was bleaching, my lips are dark and my face is much lighter then my neck. I embrace my dark skin. I’m highly upset that I was scammed effecting my confidence.
Kathrin Lutz
Nov 05,2024Top Produkts and very fast shipping.
Calvin Toole
Oct 29,2024Shipping said 5-7 days. Ordered on oct 19th and didn’t get tracking until oct 29th with delivery date nov 4th. That’s 16 days. Never again
ELA KWIECIEN
Oct 11,2024Order came promptly to UK , tracking number and Fedex service excellent, product as described. Well done guys! super happy
Georgette
Sep 19,2024I have ordered products from Editors’Pick several times and have always been completely satisfied. I recently ordered Obagi Sun Shield Tint Broad Spectrum SPF 50. It arrived when expected in excellent condition. You cannot beat Editors’Pick prices; they carry most of the most popular beauty items. I recommend them highly.
Cathy Docimo
Sep 15,2024I received the Elemis restructuring pads. The seal wasn't there, and there are only half the pads in it!! And they are drying out.
AP
Sep 10,2024I have ordered from Editor's Pick twice, hoping for the best after reading some reviews. So far, product has arrived relatively fast and sealed - which is an issue for me as I live at 4000' altitude. (Ordered IS Clinical Active Peel System in Aug 2023 and Kevin Murphy Plumping Wash Sept 2024.)
Jennifer Nettles
Aug 26,2024I ordered products from this website of course because their prices are cheaper. However I did not receive all of my products and the hair products I did receive were not in boxes or sealed. When I put in a claim with customer service I received no apology and no compensation. So I too will have to go through my bank to dispute the charges and file a complaint with the better business bureau. Cheaper is not always better ladies.
Katie
Aug 21,2024Great prices and selection.
betty
Feb 21,2025I initially liked that the prices for eminence items are low. However it is obvious that one of my items did not have a box and I suspect it had been used/ opened by someone else. Further, they seem to allow returns if the original packaging is retuened with product. I am questioning whether other ordered items had been returns. Maybe they were tried. Can’t imagine ordering from them again with this uncertainty. I also emailed them and called them -with no response. I don’t have trust.